"Katy was a huge cornerstone of 'American Idol' as far as a presence and a personality, so you can never replace her -- It's just a new era of the show," Michaels Wolflick said. P

Underwood received rave reviews for her first episode, with many viewers taking to X to admit that they prefer her over Perry. “Carrie is so much better than Katy Perry,” one person wrote. Another said, “Jukebox Carrie Underwood is way better than Katy Perry sorry not sorry,” and someone else added, “Hate to say this… I’m glad Katy left.”